Last Updated:
February 7, 2026
Thatch is a naturally occurring layer of organic material that develops at the surface of the soil beneath your grass. Though a small amount of thatch is normal and even helpful, too much of it can interfere with common lawn care practice, especially aeration.
Problems arise when thatch becomes overly thick. In these situations, aeration often fails to deliver the results homeowners expect because the soil is partially shielded. Removing excessive thatch first helps ensure aeration actually reaches compacted soil and produces longer-lasting improvements in turf health.
Many homeowners assume that thatch is simply a layer of leftover grass clippings. In reality, clippings break down quickly and rarely contribute to thatch buildup. True thatch is made up of a tightly woven mix of living and dead plant material, including roots, stems, crowns, and runners, that accumulates between the soil surface and the blades of grass.
A thin layer of thatch can be beneficial. It helps insulate the soil, reduce moisture loss, and cushion the lawn from foot traffic. Thatch becomes a problem only when it builds up faster than it can decompose, forming a dense mat that disrupts normal movement of air, water, and nutrients into the soil.
Not every lawn with thatch needs intervention. The thickness of the layer is what matters most. Lawns with less than roughly half an inch of thatch typically function without issue. Once that layer grows thicker, it begins to interfere with basic lawn processes.
Excessive thatch can cause several issues, including:
Aeration is designed to relieve compacted soil by removing small plugs from the ground. These openings allow air, water, and nutrients to move deeper into the soil profile, encouraging roots to grow downward rather than staying shallow. Over time, this leads to stronger turf, improved drought resistance, and healthier overall growth.
For aeration to be effective, the soil must be easily accessible. When roots can take advantage of loosened soil immediately, they respond quickly and fill in the aeration holes. A thick thatch layer disrupts this process by creating a barrier between the grass and the soil beneath it.
Both dethatching and aeration place stress on the lawn, so timing is critical. These services should be performed during periods of active growth, when grass can recover quickly and fill in damaged areas. Performing them at the wrong time of year can slow recovery and leave the lawn vulnerable to weeds and disease.
If significant thatch removal is necessary, allowing the lawn a short recovery period before aeration can reduce stress,especially for turf that is already thin or struggling.
When a lawn has a thick thatch layer, aeration equipment may struggle to reach the soil properly. Instead of pulling clean soil plugs, aerator tines may get caught in organic debris or fail to penetrate deeply enough to relieve compaction.
Excess thatch can:
Thatch removal should come before aeration when the thatch layer is clearly interfering with soil contact. Lawns that feel unusually spongy, drain poorly, or show weak responses to watering and fertilization often benefit from dethatching before aeration.
By removing thatch first, the soil surface is exposed, allowing aeration equipment to penetrate properly. This combination creates a two-step improvement: eliminating the barrier and then correcting soil compaction.
Not every lawn needs dethatching before aeration. Lawns with minimal thatch often respond very well to aeration alone, especially when supported by proper mowing, watering, and fertilization. In fact, routine aeration can help slow future thatch buildup by improving soil biology and encouraging organic material to break down naturally.
Grass variety also plays an important role. Some lawns are simply more prone to thatch accumulation and require closer monitoring over time.
Certain grasses, especially those that spread through stolons or rhizomes, tend to accumulate thatch more quickly. Many warm-season grasses and aggressive cool-season varieties can develop thatch faster when overwatered or overfertilized.
Knowing your grass type helps determine whether dethatching before aeration is necessary or whether aeration alone will be effective. Tailoring lawn care practices to the growth habits of your turf reduces long-term thatch issues.
Q: Can a thick thatch layer cause dry spots in my lawn?
A: Yes. Excessive thatch can prevent water from reaching the soil evenly, which often leads to dry or stressed patches even when the lawn is watered regularly.
Q: Will overseeding work if I don’t remove heavy thatch first?
A: Not very well. Seeds need direct soil contact to germinate, and thick thatch can block that contact, reducing germination rates.
Q: Can soil compaction make thatch problems worse?
A: Yes. Compacted soil limits microbial activity that breaks down organic material, allowing thatch to accumulate more quickly.
Q: Is power raking the same thing as dethatching?
A: Power raking is one method of dethatching. It’s more aggressive than standard raking and is typically used when thatch buildup is significant.
Q: Should thatch removal be followed by fertilization?
A: In many cases, yes. Light fertilization after dethatching can help the lawn recover faster, provided it’s done during the correct growing season.
Q: Can too much fertilization increase thatch buildup?
A: Absolutely. Excess nitrogen can cause rapid top growth, leading to more organic material accumulating faster than it can decompose.
Welcome to Little John’s Lawns! We are a family-owned company that specializes in providing professional lawn maintenance, lawn care, and irrigation services in Gilbert, Chandler, Mesa, and Queen Creek, AZ.